The Supreme Court on Monday declined to take up a free-speech challenge to a California requirement that instructors teach doctors renewing their medical licenses about implicit bias, according to a report by The Hill. The outlet said the challenge fell "one vote short" of earning the justices' attention.
Three conservative justices, Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito and Neil Gorsuch, wanted to take up the challenge, The Hill reported. Four votes were required to grant review, and the report indicated that the three were not enough. The account does not describe how the other six justices voted on the petition.
The challenge was brought by Azadeh Khatibi, an ophthalmologist, and another plaintiff, The Hill reported. The outlet described the case as a free-speech challenge to a requirement that applies to physicians renewing their licenses in California. The second plaintiff is not identified in the portion of the report available for this story.
The Hill's account, written by Zach Schonfeld and published Monday, does not give the Court's reasoning or any written opinion associated with the decision. It also does not describe the proceedings in the lower courts. No other news reports were available for comparison, so the details in this story rest on that single account.
The requirement at issue applies to doctors who must complete instruction on implicit bias when renewing their medical licenses in California, as The Hill described it. Because the petition did not gain the fourth vote, the case will not be heard by the Supreme Court on the basis of this order, the outlet indicated.
Sources: The Hill: Supreme Court won’t review implicit bias mandate for California medical courses.