The Nation

Judge Says Rollins' Christian Messages to Agriculture Staff Went Too Far

A federal judge said Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins' Christian messages to department staff put enough pressure on employees to raise a First Amendment violation, Axios reported.

The American Intelligencer standing plate
From the pages of The American Intelligencer.

A federal judge ruled that Christian messages sent by Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins to department employees went "too far," according to an Axios report.

Axios reported that the judge found the messages put enough pressure on staff to raise a First Amendment violation. The outlet, reporting by Avery Lotz, added that the Supreme Court has repeatedly weighed the boundaries of the Establishment Clause.

Axios also reported that the judge said Rollins could express her religious beliefs, though the full qualifying language is not contained in the excerpt available for this story.

Fox News reported that Judge Trina Thompson blocked Rollins from sharing religious messaging, ruling that her USDA Christmas and Easter emails were coercive to employees. The Fox News headline refers to holiday emails from top Trump officials that called Jesus "our Savior," but its summary names only Rollins.

The two accounts differ on several details. Axios's excerpt does not name the judge or say whether an order was issued, while Fox News identifies the judge as Trina Thompson and says the ruling blocked Rollins from sharing religious messaging.

Both outlets describe the messages as placing pressure on employees, with Axios saying they applied enough pressure to raise a First Amendment violation and Fox News calling the emails coercive.

Neither the Axios nor the Fox News material available for this story includes a response from the Agriculture Department or from Rollins, or says whether the ruling has been appealed.

Sources: Axios: Trump secretary's Christian messages to staff went "too far," judge rules; Fox News: Top Trump officials' holiday emails to staff calling Jesus 'our Savior' went 'too far,' judge rules.