The Nation

Column Argues License Plate Scanners Defy the Constitution

An opinion column in The Hill argues that license plate scanners defy the Constitution and that courts must uphold drivers' privacy rights.

The American Intelligencer standing plate
From the pages of The American Intelligencer.

According to The Hill, an opinion column published November 21, 2026, argues that license plate scanners defy the Constitution and that courts must uphold drivers' privacy rights. The column was written by Andreia Trifoi, whom The Hill identifies as an opinion contributor. It is available through The Hill's column on license plate readers and drivers' privacy.

The column's summary, as published by The Hill, draws a distinction between two activities. It states there is "a big difference between observing a car on a public road" and giving the government the ability to reconstruct a person's movements over weeks or months. The summary does not name the agencies that operate the scanners and does not describe any particular case.

The headline frames the argument in legal terms, stating that courts must uphold drivers' privacy rights. The Hill's listing does not indicate whether any court has taken up the question the column addresses. The materials available for this report do not include a response from law enforcement agencies, scanner operators, or government officials.

The Hill's listing classifies the piece as opinion, meaning it presents the views of its author rather than the reporting of the outlet's news staff. The sources for this report contain no reporting from other outlets on the column's claims, so the arguments described here are those the column makes, as summarized by The Hill.

Sources: The Hill: License plate scanners defy the Constitution - courts must uphold drivers’ privacy rights.