November 1972 · National edition

Commerce

On Oil Prices, and the bipartisan habit of selective memory

A Commerce desk reading of oil prices, filed 1972-11.

From the file. Written for the paper dated November 1972. Opened in the public stacks July 14, 2026.

As oil prices continue to fluctuate and impact the American economy, a curious trend emerges: the bipartisan habit of selective memory regarding the causes and consequences of these price changes.

Skins Trading Fur Merchants Corporation, New York, letter, 1975. Letter to the German publisher, fur dyer and fur trader Richard Franke (*18. August 1901; †2 4.
Skins Trading Fur Merchants Corporation, New York, letter, 1975. Letter to the German publisher, fur dyer and fur trader Richard Franke (*18. August 1901; †2 4. Februar 1976). Photo: Skins Trading Fur Merchants Corporation via Wikimedia Commons

Current Landscape of Oil Prices

In recent months, oil prices have seen a significant rise, catching the attention of consumers and policymakers alike. As the winter approaches, heating oil costs are a pressing concern for households across the nation. The price per barrel has surged, and the ramifications are felt in every sector reliant on oil, from transportation to manufacturing. This spike has led to renewed discussions in Congress, as both parties scramble to address the economic impact on their constituents.

Selectively Remembering the Past

However, as the politicians take to their platforms to rally for change and relief for the American people, one cannot help but notice the pattern of selective memory that pervades both sides of the aisle. Democrats and Republicans alike have been quick to assign blame for the rising oil prices to their adversaries while conveniently glossing over their own contributions to the situation.

Du Quoin Gas Station
Du Quoin Gas Station. Photo: National Archives
"It seems that in the heat of political battle, the facts become casualties, and the truth is often sacrificed for the sake of rhetoric."

Take, for instance, the Democratic leadership's calls for greater regulation of the oil industry. They argue that corporate greed is the primary driver of price increases, echoing sentiments from grassroots movements. Yet, the same leaders have historically resisted measures to promote energy independence and alternative sources of energy, opting instead to lean heavily on foreign oil imports. This inconsistency raises questions about their commitment to a sustainable solution.

On the Republican side, there is a tendency to champion deregulation and free market principles, holding a firm belief that the invisible hand will guide prices back down. However, this ideology often overlooks the reality that unregulated markets can lead to monopolistic practices, where a handful of companies can dictate prices without fear of accountability. Their previous policies have contributed to the current crisis, but they prefer to lay blame at the feet of international events or the actions of the Democrats.

Political Posturing Amid Crisis

In the midst of this oil price crisis, both parties are engaging in political posturing that distracts from the underlying issues at hand. Instead of coming together to formulate a cohesive energy policy that addresses both current needs and future sustainability, they engage in a blame game that serves only to deepen divisions.

The American public deserves better than this display of partisan infighting. It is crucial for lawmakers to recognize the complexities of the oil market and the various factors that contribute to price fluctuations, including geopolitical tensions, supply chain disruptions, and domestic production levels. Acknowledging past mistakes and working collaboratively towards a comprehensive energy strategy would be a far more productive approach.

The Path Forward

As we look to the future, it is imperative that our leaders abandon their selective memory and embrace a more honest dialogue about the energy crisis. This means acknowledging the failures of past policies while also recognizing the need for innovative solutions that prioritize energy independence and environmental sustainability.

In the coming months, both parties have the opportunity to demonstrate true leadership. They can work together to invest in renewable energy sources, incentivize conservation efforts, and ensure that the American consumer is not left to bear the brunt of rising oil prices alone. It is time to move beyond partisan politics and commit to a future where energy is both affordable and sustainable.


✦ ✦ ✦