September 1970 · National edition

Commerce

Consumer Confidence: A Middle Reading Of The Week

A Commerce desk reading of consumer confidence, filed 1970-09.

From the file. Written for the paper dated September 1970. Opened in the public stacks July 14, 2026.

As the autumn leaves begin to drop, consumer confidence teeters on a precarious ledge, influenced not only by economic indicators but also by the prevailing political climate.

Factory Smoke Blankets Clark Avenue
Factory Smoke Blankets Clark Avenue. Photo: National Archives

Current Sentiment

Recent surveys indicate that consumer confidence is experiencing fluctuations, caught between the optimism of a recovering economy and the anxiety stemming from rising inflation and political unrest. While some indicators show a slight uptick in consumer spending, the overall mood remains cautious.

In the early days of September, shoppers flocked to stores, encouraged by back-to-school sales and the lingering effects of summer spending. However, reports from retailers suggest that many consumers are still keeping a tight grip on their wallets, wary of the economic uncertainties that loom large. The juxtaposition of high consumer engagement and low confidence creates a paradox that has left economists scratching their heads.

Shredded Steel to Be Recycled. ( ..
Shredded Steel to Be Recycled. ( . Photo: National Archives

The Left's Perspective

On the left side of the political spectrum, advocates for social reform argue that consumer confidence is undermined by the government’s perceived neglect of working-class citizens. They posit that issues such as income inequality and lack of affordable healthcare are driving a wedge between consumers and their spending habits. Activists are calling for increased minimum wages and better labor protections, suggesting that these measures would enhance consumer confidence by providing a more stable economic foundation.

"Until we address the fundamental inequalities in our society, consumer confidence will remain an elusive goal." - a leading activist

However, while these calls for reform resonate with many, the left's approach often seems to overlook the immediate economic realities that many consumers face. By focusing heavily on systemic inequalities, they may risk alienating moderate consumers who fear that radical changes could further destabilize the economy.

The Right's Viewpoint

Conversely, the right emphasizes fiscal conservatism, advocating for tax cuts and deregulation as pathways to boost consumer confidence. Proponents argue that reducing taxes will leave more money in the pockets of consumers, thereby encouraging spending. However, this position often glosses over the complexities of the current economic landscape, including the inflationary pressures that are diminishing purchasing power.

"Tax cuts will empower consumers and stimulate the economy; it's time for the government to step back." - a prominent economist

The right's insistence on tax reductions and minimal regulation can come across as overly simplistic, failing to acknowledge that many consumers are grappling with immediate concerns about job security and rising prices. Their approach may inadvertently widen the gap of misunderstanding between various economic classes, as it does not fully address the fears and frustrations felt by lower-income households.

A Middle Ground

Amidst these polarized perspectives, the need for a middle ground becomes glaringly evident. Rather than retreating to extremes, both sides must engage in a constructive dialogue that acknowledges the validity of each other's concerns. A balanced approach that considers both social equity and economic stability could be essential in restoring consumer confidence.

Policymakers must find ways to address the pressing issues of inflation and job insecurity while also considering the social safety nets that can support the most vulnerable among us. This entails crafting a comprehensive economic strategy that includes targeted tax relief for lower-income families, investments in education and job training, and a focus on sustainable economic growth.

Looking Forward

As we move further into September, the economy's trajectory remains uncertain. Consumer confidence will likely continue to waver unless a coherent strategy emerges that encompasses the diverse needs of the population. The coming weeks will be crucial as we witness how external factors, such as the ongoing political discourse and economic policies, play out in the marketplace.


✦ ✦ ✦