November 1973 ยท National edition

The Nation

Oil, Lines, and the Politics of Scarcity

Rationing theater versus the boring arithmetic of supply.

From the file. Written for the paper dated November 1973. Opened in the public stacks July 14, 2026.

The United States is experiencing a palpable sense of urgency and anxiety as the energy crisis continues to unfold. Long lines at gas stations have become a common sight across the nation, and the implications for both consumers and the economy are profound.

Feeding the Ducks on Lake Washington. Lake Washington Was Dying of Pollution Caused by Sewage. Under the Metro...
Feeding the Ducks on Lake Washington. Lake Washington Was Dying of Pollution Caused by Sewage. Under the Metro. Photo: National Archives
"The politics of scarcity will shape not only our energy policy but also the very fabric of American society."The American Intelligencer

The recent decision by the Organization of Arab Petroleum Exporting Countries (OAPEC) to impose an oil embargo on nations supporting Israel in the Yom Kippur War has further exacerbated the situation, leading to a dramatic surge in oil prices and a stark realization of our reliance on foreign oil.

The Immediate Impact

As citizens wait in line for hours to fill their tanks, the political ramifications are becoming increasingly evident. The Nixon Administration has been scrambling to respond to the crisis, announcing measures to reduce consumption, including a national speed limit and calls for conservation. However, these efforts have been met with skepticism. Critics argue that the administration's response is more theatrical than substantive, focusing on temporary solutions rather than addressing the root causes of our energy dependency.

Many Americans are beginning to question the long-term sustainability of a system that relies heavily on a volatile international market. The energy crisis has brought to the forefront discussions about domestic oil production, renewable energy sources, and the need for a comprehensive energy policy. The Pentagon is reportedly concerned about national security implications, as our reliance on foreign oil could be seen as a vulnerability in times of geopolitical tension.


Rationing and Its Discontents

As the crisis deepens, discussions about potential rationing have gained traction. Some lawmakers are advocating for a system that would allocate gasoline based on need, while others warn of the dangers of government overreach and the specter of a command economy. The idea of rationing has historically been met with resistance in a nation that prides itself on individual freedoms and market dynamics.

View from Fourth Street of the front entrance and marble columns of the Alaska State Capitol as it appeared in the early-mid 1970s.
View from Fourth Street of the front entrance and marble columns of the Alaska State Capitol as it appeared in the early-mid 1970s. Photo: Elaine B. Mitchell (editor) via Wikimedia Commons

The notion of rationing evokes memories of World War II, when Americans willingly accepted restrictions for the greater good. However, the political landscape has changed significantly since then. The public's trust in government has been shaken by events such as the Watergate scandal, leading many to view any government intervention with suspicion. The challenge for policymakers will be to strike a balance between necessary intervention and maintaining public confidence.


The Politics of Scarcity

The ongoing crisis has also illuminated the fractures within American politics. On one side, there are those who advocate for immediate government action and regulation to manage the supply and demand of oil. On the other, a more libertarian perspective argues for minimal intervention, positing that market forces will ultimately resolve the crisis. This debate reflects a larger ideological divide that has become increasingly pronounced in recent years.

While some may argue that the solution lies in increased drilling and exploitation of domestic resources, others caution against such an approach, warning that it could have long-term environmental consequences. The recent oil spills and environmental degradation associated with drilling activities have not been forgotten by the public. A more sustainable approach would require a serious investment in alternative energy sources, but this would necessitate a level of political will and cooperation that remains elusive.


Looking Ahead

As Congress grapples with the intricacies of energy policy, the American public is left to navigate the immediate challenges of rising prices and dwindling supplies. The question remains: how will we balance the imperatives of energy security with the values of a free society? The coming months will be critical as we confront these challenges head-on. The energy crisis may very well be a turning point for our nation, forcing us to reassess our priorities and approach to energy consumption.

With winter approaching, the stakes are higher than ever. Heating oil prices are expected to rise, and families across the country will be forced to make difficult choices. It is imperative that we not only address the current crisis but also lay the groundwork for a more sustainable and resilient energy future.

As the lines at gas stations grow longer and the rhetoric in Washington intensifies, it is clear that the politics of scarcity will shape not only our energy policy but also the very fabric of American society. The challenge lies ahead: will we rise to meet it with innovative solutions, or will we succumb to fear and division? The answer may well define the course of our nation in the years to come.

✦ ✦ ✦

Portal video Economic machine explainer (used as structural reference for stagflation-era pieces)