December 2017 · National edition

The Nation

On Shutdown Brinkmanship, and a middle reading of the week

A The Nation desk reading of shutdown brinkmanship, filed 2017-12.

From the file. Written for the paper dated December 2017. Opened in the public stacks July 14, 2026.

As December unfolds, the specter of government shutdown looms over Washington, revealing the stark divisions and excesses of both political parties. The brinkmanship surrounding budget negotiations reflects not just a failure of governance but also a troubling trend of polarization that has gripped the nation.

Barack Obama 2013
Barack Obama 2013. Photo: The White House

The Shutdown Showdown

As Congress enters the final stretch of the year, the stakes have never been higher. With a December 22 deadline looming, lawmakers find themselves at an impasse over critical issues such as funding for the Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP) and border security. Both parties are digging in their heels, and the prospect of a government shutdown has become a bargaining chip in a game of political poker.

X post from @NASA
X thread screenshot · frame 1/3 @NASA - open original. Thread screenshots sit in the story so the record can be read without leaving the page.

On one side, Democrats are rightfully advocating for protections for vulnerable populations, including children and low-income families. They argue that the government should not be held hostage over partisan disagreements. Yet, there is a troubling tendency among some Democrats to use these issues as a means to score political points rather than genuinely seeking compromise. The rhetoric of “resistance” often morphs into a refusal to engage in meaningful dialogue.

President Barack Obama greets Boston Red Sox outfielder Jonny Gomes during a White House event honoring the team and their 2013 World Series Championship, April
President Barack Obama greets Boston Red Sox outfielder Jonny Gomes during a White House event honoring the team and their 2013 World Series Championship, April 1, 2014. Photo: The White House

Meanwhile, Republicans, emboldened by their control of both Congress and the presidency, have adopted a hardline stance that prioritizes tax cuts and military spending over social programs. The insistence on funding for a border wall, a key campaign promise, has become a focal point of contention. It raises questions about their commitment to the very constituents they claim to represent, particularly those who depend on government services.

X post from @Debriefmedia
X thread screenshot · frame 2/3 @Debriefmedia - open original. Thread screenshots sit in the story so the record can be read without leaving the page.
“The government should not be held hostage over partisan disagreements.”

Polarization at Play

The current situation exemplifies a larger trend of polarization that has seeped into every facet of American political life. Extremist rhetoric has become the norm, with both sides frequently demonizing the other. The left often paints conservatives as heartless and out of touch, while the right characterizes progressives as unpatriotic and radical. This binary thinking stifles constructive dialogue and fosters an environment where compromise is seen as weakness.

Media narratives often exacerbate this divide, amplifying the most extreme voices while neglecting the moderate majority. As a result, voters are left feeling alienated and disillusioned. The constant barrage of partisan sound bites and outrage-driven headlines creates a climate where rational discourse feels nearly impossible. It is imperative that both sides recognize the dangers of this approach and work towards a more measured, solution-oriented style of politics.

X post from @cspan
X thread screenshot · frame 3/3 @cspan - open original. Thread screenshots sit in the story so the record can be read without leaving the page.

The Middle Ground

In the face of these alarming trends, it is the moderates - those who occupy the middle ground - who offer the most promising path forward. These individuals, often overlooked, play a critical role in bridging the divide. They understand that compromise is necessary for progress and that governance requires a willingness to engage with differing perspectives.

One of the most pressing issues at hand is the urgent need for a bipartisan budget agreement that ensures the continued functioning of government without sacrificing essential services. Both parties must come to the table and negotiate in good faith, recognizing that the stakes are too high for political posturing.

Conclusion: A Call for Civility

The current political climate demands a renewed commitment to civility and cooperation. As the deadline approaches, it is imperative that both parties set aside their differences and prioritize the needs of the American people over political gain. A government shutdown would only serve to further erode public trust in our institutions and exacerbate the very divisions that have come to define our political landscape.

In the coming days, let us hope that reason prevails and that lawmakers choose to engage in a spirit of compromise rather than confrontation. The American people deserve leaders who are willing to put aside their partisan agendas and work towards a common good. The future of governance may depend on it.

✦ ✦ ✦